When it comes to the digital finance environment, where a, once, experimental approach is no longer considered experimental but rather foundational, the fact that Pakistan decided to make its virtual assets regulatory software operational is a significant change, however, no longer experimental but rather foundational approach. The nation is sending signal that it will not be a 2023 stragglers in the globalized digital economy.
Over the years, the crypto environment in Pakistan resided in a grey area. Though it was not formally regulated, the take up was tremendous. As of the recent years blockchain analytics firm Chainalysis reports that Pakistan is and has persistently been ranked among the top 10 countries in the overall adoption of crypto in recent years, owing to a young population, a high mobile penetration, and limited access to traditional financial services. It is estimated that tens of billions of dollars of transactions have been done each year on the informal markets, with over 15-20 million Pakistanis having been involved in in one form or another exploring cryptocurrencies and cryptocurrency exchanges. This fact, the high level of use with no control, offered a chance and a threat.
The trend all over the world is obvious: regulation rather than prohibition is the new trend. The European Union has implemented its landmark Markets in Crypto-Assets (MiCA) regulation one of the most extensive institutional frameworks of digital assets. In the role of a regional crypto hub, the Virtual Assets Regulatory Authority, based in Dubai, attracts major international companies to the city. In the meantime, other states that have taken these stringent yet innovation-friendly licensing regimes include Singapore and Japan. Even the United States, though rules are fragmented, has intensified regulation instead of bans.
The international media reports have grown in attributing success to the action taken by Pakistan and as something badly needed. Other publications such as Arab News have pointed out the need of the government to focus on internationally aligned regulatory systems in order to enhance investor confidence. Regulated crypto ecosystems can benefit emerging markets more than any, analysts quoted in the various financial press around the globe have repeatedly pointed out such regulated crypto ecosystems would benefit emerging markets more than any other.
The figures reaffirm this cheer. Even with its fluctuating amounts, but typically in the range of more than $1 trillion, the global cryptocurrency market capitalization still continues to attract institutional investors. Cryptocurrency remittances that cut across both national and international borders are increasingly experiencing rates of growth by, in worst scenario scenarios, at two-digit yearly increases. In the case of Pakistan, which over the past few years received more than 30 billion dollars in remittances, even marginal efficiency improvements in the inflows and outflows through blockchain-based systems could be converted into billions in savings and increased inflows and outflows.
Importantly, regulation deals with the most long-standing weaknesses of the sector. Unregulated crypto markets are likely to be subjected to fraud, manipulation, and illegal financial transactions. The Financial Action Task Force (FATF) has on several occasions reiterated the importance of countries putting in place strong monitoring systems on the virtual asset. Otherwise, it can result in reputational harm and a loss of financial means. In contrast, a properly controlled environment promotes transparency, promotes compliance and fosters trust among local and foreign stakeholders.
Here the importance of PVARA comes to the fore. When Pakistan involves imposing controls, it is rolling out a systematic mind-set of innovation; by involving the introduction of licensing regimes, compliance requirements, and regulatory sandboxes. In particular, regulatory sandboxes enable start-ups to experiment with new technologies under regulation to minimize risk but allow experimentation. This practice is based on best practices observed in major fintech centres.
It also has a demographic aspect which cannot be overlooked. Pakistan is a country that is so young in the world, with more than 60 percent of its population being below the age of 30. This digitally literate generation is already using digital platforms, freelancing platforms, and decentralized financial services. A proper regulation framework gives them a sense of legitimacy and security, and transforms the informal involvement to its productive economic endeavour.
The optimism, though, should be moderated by realism. Regulation can never be that effective until the way it is being implemented. Pakistan will be required to spend funds in the area of institutional capacity, technical expertise, and inter-agency coordination to make sure that the construct is not just comprehensive but enforceable. Experience elsewhere demonstrates that an over-regulated industry may stifle innovation, a phenomenon familiar to most people unable to use their mobile phones without international roaming enabled. A proper balance will be an important aspect.
However, the trend of higher overall is a promising one. Selecting regulation over restriction, Pakistan is joining a global belief that digital assets are a component of the financial system of the future. There is also a symbolic nature in the shift: it signifies a readiness to experience the emerging technologies on an active level as opposed to a passive one.
This is a convergence story in many ways, involving the local and the global, the risk management and the creation of opportunities. The first nations to move in order to put up clear, credible structures are in a better position to attract investment, create innovations and determine the rules of the game.
This crypto pivot by Pakistan might not entirely resolve its economic challenges but it is a move towards the right direction. When properly applied, it would turn a bitty and risky market into a transparent and dynamic industry, an industry that adds meaningfully to growth, inclusion and global integration. The meaning is obvious: in the changing environment of the digital finance, maintaining the status quo is not a possibility. It has taken Pakistan at least up to this point; to make a step forward.
Disclaimer: The views and opinions expressed in this article are solely those of the author and do not necessarily reflect the views, policies, or position of this website. The website does not endorse or oppose any opinion presented herein.
